Alden 3557 Black Calfskin LHS / Penny Loafer
Additional Model Details:
Plaza Last (true to size)
Single Leather Outsole
270 Flat Welt
Plaza Slip-On
Alden 3557 eBay Sales (last 50):
When you click on links to make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission from the eBay Partner Network.
Alden 3557 Black Calfskin Penny Loafers | Plaza Last | Mens 12 B/D
- Condition: Pre-owned
- Size: 12 D
- End: 2026-06-15 3:16 PM
- Duration: 14 days, 0 hr, 42 min
- $175.00 Sold
- Times Listed: 1
Up for sale is a classic pair of Alden 3557 Black Calfskin Penny Loafers built on the elegant Plaza Last. Featuring a slightly structured, soft squared toe, this traditional silhouette offers a sophisticated profile that pairs perfectly with everything from tailored trousers to vintage denim and workwear silhouettes.
Alden shoes are benchmark examples of American heritage shoemaking, crafted with an exceptional level of build quality, Goodyear welt construction, and robust single oak leather outsoles.
Condition Report
These shoes are in excellent pre-owned condition and have been very well cared for:
Uppers: The black calfskin leather is supple and healthy, showing only normal, light creasing across the vamps. They take a beautiful shine. No deep gouges, scuffs, or tears.
Insoles: Very clean with zero odors. The original gold leaf Alden New England heel pad stamps are crisp, dark, and fully legible, indicating these have not been heavily worn down.
Outsoles: The leather soles remain firm with the original channel stitching fully intact around the toe and welt line.
Heels: Features a brand-new, unworn rubber dovetail heel replacement. You will not need to take these to a cobbler anytime soon—they are ready to wear straight out of the box!
Stored with cedar shoe trees in a smoke-free, pet-free home.
Sizing Note
Please know your size in Alden's Plaza Last before bidding. The size is marked 10 B/D. In Alden's sizing convention, the top letter (B) designates the heel width, and the bottom letter (D) designates the forefoot/ball width. The Plaza last generally runs true-to-size for standard US dress shoe sizing.
Shipping & Returns
Ships promptly via USPS Priority Mail with tracking.
Feel free to message me with any questions or if you need additional measurements!
Rare Alden 3557 Black Calf Loafer Size US 8 C/E
- Condition: Pre-owned
- Size: 8 C/E Split Width
- End: 2026-05-19 8:30 AM
- Duration: 1 days, 7 hr, 20 min
- $149.95 Sold
- Times Listed: 1
The Alden Black Calf Loafer in US size 8 with a C/E split width is a rare and vintage piece of men's dress shoe. Made in the United States with premium calfskin leather, this loafer features a round toe shape, slip-on closure, and a classic solid black color. The shoe is designed with a Goodyear welted outsole and is recraftable, making it a versatile and timeless addition to any wardrobe. With its combination of style, quality, and craftsmanship, this Alden loafer embodies the traditional and sophisticated aesthetic of classic men's footwear. They show some marks. See pictures
Men's Alden 3557 Plaza Black Penny Loafers Size 12 D
- Condition: See item
- Size: 12 D
- End: 2026-03-09 1:22 AM
- Duration: 4 days, 23 hr
- $149.99 Sold
- Times Listed: 3
Men's pre-owned, black calf uppers, apron toe, half strap penny loafers by Alden Plaza, model no3557, in size 12 D. Made in USA. In great used condition. The outer sole measurements are; 12 3/4" long & 4 1/2" wide. Please email me your questions. The shoe trees are included. BUYERS WITH FEEDBACK SCORE OF LESS THAN 10 ARE REQUIRED TO PAY IMMEDIATELY.
COMBINED SHIPPING AVAILABLE
LOW BALL BIDDERS WILL BE BLOCKED FROM FUTURE LISTINGS
Alden 10.5 Black Penny Loafer Coin
- Condition: Pre-owned
- Size: 10.5 B
- End: 2025-12-23 8:30 PM
- Duration: 11 days, 19 hr, 30 min
- $300.00 Sold
- Times Listed: 2
To be perfectly honest, I dont' know enough about these shoes to write an accurate description. I've tried to research, but I'm just confused. Please ask questions, and I'll try and answer them!
Alden New England Men’s Black Leather Penny Loafer Dress Shoe 9.5 Old Money
- Condition: Pre-owned
- Size: 9.5 D
- End: 2025-11-14 5:16 AM
- Duration: 8 hr, 37 min
- $124.87 Sold
- Times Listed: 2
Very nice condition
Minor scuffs